With a Description of the Moon
Quick! Pick a card, any card.
Now think of a number between 1 and 10.
Next think of a colour.
And a vegetable.
Got them all?
Carrot, red, 7 and either the Ace of Spades or the Queen of Hearts, failing that something with a 3 or a 7 in it (almost definitely not the Nine of Clubs).
If any or all of your answers match these then you have just fallen prey to cognitive bias. It’s a funny little quirk of human nature that has long been taken advantage of by street magicians. Our brains collectively tend to follow similar pathways and for some reason these are the answers that those pathways most often lead us to. I’m not sure why this is but Derren Brown would probably know.
Not everyone will come up with these answers but if you ask enough people you will start to see a definite trend.
Incidentally, I have noticed a similarly hard to explain and seemingly random trend in how new writers choose to start their novels. I can’t explain this one either (maybe even Derren would fail to) but after some time of reading the opening lines of submissions I found myself thinking, “wow, people really like the moon, don’t they?”
And they do.
Once I had noticed this particular submission phenomenon the moon suddenly seemed to be everywhere I looked in opening paragraphs and spooky prologues. It makes a certain amount of sense, granted. Mentioning the moon in your opening line immediately lets your reader know that it is night-time, which is useful. I suppose it also creates a certain gothic atmosphere or maybe suggests that something clandestine might be happening but overall I can’t quite fathom why it pops up so very often as an opening image.
But it does.
It’s not even as if new writers are emanating a popular narrative technique in this case, not as far as I can tell. I personally couldn’t think of any examples of this one from well-known novels. Can you think of one? There must be at least one published novel that begins by describing the moon.
Because there are definitely a lot of unpublished novels that start that way.
There’s nothing wrong with it at all, just as there is nothing amiss if you immediately visualised 7 red carrots sitting on the Ace of Spades. It’s just not original. Oddly.
So, in the interest of standing out from the crowd avoid describing the moon in your opening line. And maybe next time go with aubergine.
By Vicki Le Feuvre
8 Comments Add yours
How interesting! But if you’re not copying published novels, you wouldn’t necessarily know it’s a cliché.
I can only think of one time I’ve mentioned the moon in my fiction, but it’s quite hard to describe in my opinion, so wouldn’t mind some tips from these writers!
Put it down to the current fascination with the gothic! My moon mention is well into my novel in a romantic scene setting…
Well, I find a full moon in a clear night sky romantic! Dvorak even wrote a Song to the Moon for the woodsprite Rusalka, asking the moon to tell a prince of her love for him.
As I read this, Paul Auster’s Moon Palace popped into my head. Opening line “It was the summer that men first walked on the moon.”
I fight with these obvious images all the time – kicking them out as much as I can! Interesting what you said about the moon, I had noticed that, and recently I added some poems to Pinterest (no-one is that much into poetry on Pinterest!) interesting that the only one that has been liked and repinned so far, is a slightly quirky one – about the moon!! 😉
I’m not sure what the fascination with the moon is either, but I have noticed in recent years a lot of programmes on television, drama or documentary, have had very brief images of the moon appear on the screen for about 2- 5 seconds. It’s all presented as a bit arty, and creates a pause between scene changes, sometimes indicating that the next piece coming up is several hours later and is now night time – but it’s not always for that reason, some appear to have no reason at all.
It started happening so much, it really annoyed me, out of pure curiosity I began to count the amount of times it occurred. Some days I would count as many as 4 or 5 moon images appearing on programmes each day – that’s a lot of moons in a week! Perhaps this might explain some of the reasons behind why the moon ends up in writers minds! Images that are very brief and often frequent, can be very powerful – and I’m very sure the talented and ever so sharp Mr Derran Brown knows all about that little trick!! 😉
I still say that there is some intangible emotional draw for humans towards that floating orb in the night sky…the unattainable longed for state, symbolized up there, shining! Our minds work with symbols and the moon is a great symbol for something to aspire to which seems just out of reach, but still longed for.
Or am I being impossibly romantic?
Darkly Dreaming Dexter opens with the moon, but it’s really well done.
Guilty for the moon and guilty for the weather! In the same novel. 😀 On the positive note, my (Slovenian) editor who has a BA in literature loved the first chapter, despite a cliché beginning. I didn’t even know it was a cliché, until somebody pointed it out. I just thought it fits perfectly …
I really liked this article. I had a bit of trouble reading it as the only light I have is that which emanates from my old computer screen, its kind of dim.
It wouldn’t be such a problem except tonight there is such a strong moon out and it just happens to be in a position where its shining fully through the rip in the old tin roof of my shed. Its luminosity is quite amazing and yet if one looks carefully and intently you can still see all it glorious surface details despite the brightness.
The biggest problem I have with the moon is the light hurts my eyes and gives me a headache making me feel anger. I think its gravitational pull also affects my mood swings in a bad way. Sometimes when I try to write my concentration will be suddenly interrupted by the cat-like squabbling of the rats who reside here. I find I’m usually OK with their light-hearted banter, but for some reason when the moon is full my temper snaps and I yell and curse at them.
They started up again tonight while I was reading, I think they may have been fighting over a bone or a small piece of flesh or something. Probably from the burial under the concrete behind my cluttered old dusty desk.
I wouldn’t hurt them of course, they are just harmless cute little animals. Besides, if I harmed them I would have no friends left.
I found the mention of Derren ironic. I had a friend named Derren once, he was a writer too. I met him in a coffee shop and we started talking about writing,
I invited him to come and ‘read my stuff’. I was sure he’d be impressed.
You can’t even imagine my shock when he started laughing at my writing!
This after even criticizing my humble home.
I flew into a rage.
Ironically it was a full moon that night, its eerie glow lighting the pathway down into my gully.
Derren wasn’t very nice, we aren’t friends any more.
I haven’t seen him since that night.
I have to agree with this article many people seem to have a fixation with the moon.
I think its creepy. Those people are probably pretty creepy too.
I wouldn’t want creepy people like that reading my writing.
I find writing difficult enough without having to go into great detail about such superfluous ‘background noise’ like a moon.
I like this article, I want to stand out in the crowd.
I hate the moon anyway.